Theorem axhvmulid-zf

Description: Derive Axiom ax-hvmulid from Hilbert space under ZF set theory. (Contributed by NM, 31-May-2008) (New usage is discouraged.)

	Ref	Expression
Hypotheses	axhil.1	|- U = <. <. +h , .h >. , normh >.
	axhil.2	|- U e. CHilOLD
Assertion	axhvmulid-zf	|- ( A e. ~H -> ( 1 .h A ) = A )

Proof

Step	Hyp	Ref	Expression
1		axhil.1	|- U = <. <. +h , .h >. , normh >.
2		axhil.2	|- U e. CHilOLD
3		df-hba	|- ~H = ( BaseSet ` <. <. +h , .h >. , normh >. )
4	1	fveq2i	|- ( BaseSet ` U ) = ( BaseSet ` <. <. +h , .h >. , normh >. )
5	3 4	eqtr4i	|- ~H = ( BaseSet ` U )
6	2	hlnvi	|- U e. NrmCVec
7	1 6	h2hsm	|- .h = ( .sOLD ` U )
8	5 7	hlmulid	|- ( ( U e. CHilOLD /\ A e. ~H ) -> ( 1 .h A ) = A )
9	2 8	mpan	|- ( A e. ~H -> ( 1 .h A ) = A )