Metamath Proof Explorer


Theorem flt3lemB

Description: Lemma B for flt3 : The absolute values of the (first) two summands are not equal. (Contributed by AV, 4-Nov-2026)

Ref Expression
Hypotheses flt3lemA.z
|- Z = ( ZZ \ { 0 } )
flt3lemA.e
|- ( ph -> ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
flt3lemA.a
|- ( ph -> A e. Z )
flt3lemA.b
|- ( ph -> B e. Z )
flt3lemA.c
|- ( ph -> C e. Z )
Assertion flt3lemB
|- ( ph -> ( A =/= B /\ A =/= -u B ) )

Proof

Step Hyp Ref Expression
1 flt3lemA.z
 |-  Z = ( ZZ \ { 0 } )
2 flt3lemA.e
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
3 flt3lemA.a
 |-  ( ph -> A e. Z )
4 flt3lemA.b
 |-  ( ph -> B e. Z )
5 flt3lemA.c
 |-  ( ph -> C e. Z )
6 2 adantr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
7 oveq1
 |-  ( A = B -> ( A ^ 3 ) = ( B ^ 3 ) )
8 7 oveq1d
 |-  ( A = B -> ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
9 1 eleq2i
 |-  ( B e. Z <-> B e. ( ZZ \ { 0 } ) )
10 eldifsn
 |-  ( B e. ( ZZ \ { 0 } ) <-> ( B e. ZZ /\ B =/= 0 ) )
11 9 10 bitri
 |-  ( B e. Z <-> ( B e. ZZ /\ B =/= 0 ) )
12 11 simplbi
 |-  ( B e. Z -> B e. ZZ )
13 4 12 syl
 |-  ( ph -> B e. ZZ )
14 3nn0
 |-  3 e. NN0
15 14 a1i
 |-  ( ph -> 3 e. NN0 )
16 13 15 zexpcld
 |-  ( ph -> ( B ^ 3 ) e. ZZ )
17 16 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> ( B ^ 3 ) e. CC )
18 2times
 |-  ( ( B ^ 3 ) e. CC -> ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
19 18 eqcomd
 |-  ( ( B ^ 3 ) e. CC -> ( ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
20 17 19 syl
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
21 8 20 sylan9eqr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
22 21 oveq1d
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) )
23 22 eqeq1d
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> ( ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 <-> ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 ) )
24 2z
 |-  2 e. ZZ
25 24 a1i
 |-  ( ph -> 2 e. ZZ )
26 25 16 zmulcld
 |-  ( ph -> ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) e. ZZ )
27 26 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) e. CC )
28 1 eleq2i
 |-  ( C e. Z <-> C e. ( ZZ \ { 0 } ) )
29 eldifsn
 |-  ( C e. ( ZZ \ { 0 } ) <-> ( C e. ZZ /\ C =/= 0 ) )
30 28 29 bitri
 |-  ( C e. Z <-> ( C e. ZZ /\ C =/= 0 ) )
31 30 simplbi
 |-  ( C e. Z -> C e. ZZ )
32 5 31 syl
 |-  ( ph -> C e. ZZ )
33 32 15 zexpcld
 |-  ( ph -> ( C ^ 3 ) e. ZZ )
34 33 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> ( C ^ 3 ) e. CC )
35 addeq0
 |-  ( ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) e. CC /\ ( C ^ 3 ) e. CC ) -> ( ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 <-> ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) ) )
36 27 34 35 syl2anc
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 <-> ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) ) )
37 32 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> C e. CC )
38 3nn
 |-  3 e. NN
39 38 a1i
 |-  ( ph -> 3 e. NN )
40 n2dvds3
 |-  -. 2 || 3
41 40 a1i
 |-  ( ph -> -. 2 || 3 )
42 oexpneg
 |-  ( ( C e. CC /\ 3 e. NN /\ -. 2 || 3 ) -> ( -u C ^ 3 ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) )
43 37 39 41 42 syl3anc
 |-  ( ph -> ( -u C ^ 3 ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) )
44 43 eqcomd
 |-  ( ph -> -u ( C ^ 3 ) = ( -u C ^ 3 ) )
45 44 eqeq2d
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) <-> ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( -u C ^ 3 ) ) )
46 eqcom
 |-  ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( -u C ^ 3 ) <-> ( -u C ^ 3 ) = ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
47 32 znegcld
 |-  ( ph -> -u C e. ZZ )
48 47 15 zexpcld
 |-  ( ph -> ( -u C ^ 3 ) e. ZZ )
49 48 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> ( -u C ^ 3 ) e. CC )
50 25 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> 2 e. CC )
51 13 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> B e. CC )
52 11 simprbi
 |-  ( B e. Z -> B =/= 0 )
53 4 52 syl
 |-  ( ph -> B =/= 0 )
54 3z
 |-  3 e. ZZ
55 54 a1i
 |-  ( ph -> 3 e. ZZ )
56 51 53 55 expne0d
 |-  ( ph -> ( B ^ 3 ) =/= 0 )
57 49 50 17 56 divmul3d
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( ( -u C ^ 3 ) / ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 2 <-> ( -u C ^ 3 ) = ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) ) )
58 46 57 bitr4id
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( -u C ^ 3 ) <-> ( ( -u C ^ 3 ) / ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 2 ) )
59 47 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> -u C e. CC )
60 59 51 53 15 expdivd
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) = ( ( -u C ^ 3 ) / ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
61 60 eqcomd
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( -u C ^ 3 ) / ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) )
62 61 eqeq1d
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( ( -u C ^ 3 ) / ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 2 <-> ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) = 2 ) )
63 45 58 62 3bitrd
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) <-> ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) = 2 ) )
64 4 1 eleqtrdi
 |-  ( ph -> B e. ( ZZ \ { 0 } ) )
65 cuqn2
 |-  ( ( -u C e. ZZ /\ B e. ( ZZ \ { 0 } ) ) -> ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) =/= 2 )
66 47 64 65 syl2anc
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) =/= 2 )
67 eqneqall
 |-  ( ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) = 2 -> ( ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) =/= 2 -> A =/= B ) )
68 66 67 syl5com
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( ( -u C / B ) ^ 3 ) = 2 -> A =/= B ) )
69 63 68 sylbid
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) = -u ( C ^ 3 ) -> A =/= B ) )
70 36 69 sylbid
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 -> A =/= B ) )
71 70 adantr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> ( ( ( 2 x. ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 -> A =/= B ) )
72 23 71 sylbid
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> ( ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 -> A =/= B ) )
73 6 72 mpd
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = B ) -> A =/= B )
74 73 expcom
 |-  ( A = B -> ( ph -> A =/= B ) )
75 ax-1
 |-  ( A =/= B -> ( ph -> A =/= B ) )
76 74 75 pm2.61ine
 |-  ( ph -> A =/= B )
77 oveq1
 |-  ( A = -u B -> ( A ^ 3 ) = ( -u B ^ 3 ) )
78 oexpneg
 |-  ( ( B e. CC /\ 3 e. NN /\ -. 2 || 3 ) -> ( -u B ^ 3 ) = -u ( B ^ 3 ) )
79 51 39 41 78 syl3anc
 |-  ( ph -> ( -u B ^ 3 ) = -u ( B ^ 3 ) )
80 77 79 sylan9eqr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( A ^ 3 ) = -u ( B ^ 3 ) )
81 80 oveq1d
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( -u ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
82 16 znegcld
 |-  ( ph -> -u ( B ^ 3 ) e. ZZ )
83 82 zcnd
 |-  ( ph -> -u ( B ^ 3 ) e. CC )
84 83 17 addcomd
 |-  ( ph -> ( -u ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = ( ( B ^ 3 ) + -u ( B ^ 3 ) ) )
85 17 negidd
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( B ^ 3 ) + -u ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
86 84 85 eqtrd
 |-  ( ph -> ( -u ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
87 86 adantr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( -u ( B ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
88 81 87 eqtrd
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) = 0 )
89 88 oveq1d
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = ( 0 + ( C ^ 3 ) ) )
90 34 addlidd
 |-  ( ph -> ( 0 + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = ( C ^ 3 ) )
91 90 adantr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( 0 + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = ( C ^ 3 ) )
92 89 91 eqtrd
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = ( C ^ 3 ) )
93 92 eqeq1d
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 <-> ( C ^ 3 ) = 0 ) )
94 expeq0
 |-  ( ( C e. CC /\ 3 e. NN ) -> ( ( C ^ 3 ) = 0 <-> C = 0 ) )
95 37 39 94 syl2anc
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( C ^ 3 ) = 0 <-> C = 0 ) )
96 eqneqall
 |-  ( C = 0 -> ( C =/= 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
97 96 com12
 |-  ( C =/= 0 -> ( C = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
98 30 97 simplbiim
 |-  ( C e. Z -> ( C = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
99 5 98 syl
 |-  ( ph -> ( C = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
100 95 99 sylbid
 |-  ( ph -> ( ( C ^ 3 ) = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
101 100 adantr
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( C ^ 3 ) = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
102 93 101 sylbid
 |-  ( ( ph /\ A = -u B ) -> ( ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) )
103 102 ex
 |-  ( ph -> ( A = -u B -> ( ( ( ( A ^ 3 ) + ( B ^ 3 ) ) + ( C ^ 3 ) ) = 0 -> A =/= -u B ) ) )
104 2 103 mpid
 |-  ( ph -> ( A = -u B -> A =/= -u B ) )
105 104 com12
 |-  ( A = -u B -> ( ph -> A =/= -u B ) )
106 ax-1
 |-  ( A =/= -u B -> ( ph -> A =/= -u B ) )
107 105 106 pm2.61ine
 |-  ( ph -> A =/= -u B )
108 76 107 jca
 |-  ( ph -> ( A =/= B /\ A =/= -u B ) )